Our agency is proud that we have represented Wayne Mutual Insurance Group for 3 generations since Knisely Insurance opened its office doors over 50 years ago. Wayne Mutual offers home, auto, umbrella and commercial insurance. Let us quote you today and have peace of mind that you are doing business with a reputable company!


Personal – Auto, Motorcycle,
hiddentexttSR-22 Bonds,
hiddentext Home, Boat, RV,
hiddentexttCondo, Umbrella,
hiddentexttFlood, Vacant,
hiddentext Renters
Business – Business Owners
hiddentexttCommercial Auto
hiddentexttCommercial Property
hiddentexttGeneral Liability

About Us

Knisely Insurance is an independent Agency serving Crawford County & Surrounding areas for over 85 years. Colleen McCleese is the sole agent and has been affiliated with Knisely Insurance since 1983. We offer coverage with several companies so we are highly competitive. Stop in our new location or give us a call for a no obligation Quote

Contact Us

Knisely Insurance Agency Inc.
309 S. Walnut St.
Bucyrus, Ohio 44820
(419)562-5092 (fax)
Colleen McCleese, Owner/Agent
Kylie Bowman CSR

Request a Quote

Comments are closed